Totally Made-Up Hallmark Christmas Movie

Reviewed · MIDNIGHT IN THE GARDEN & MOVIE LOCATIONS TOURS

Totally Made-Up Hallmark Christmas Movie

5.0 · 5 reviews From $20 Operated by Front Porch Improv · Bookable on Viator
Book on Viator →

A made-up Christmas movie sounds silly, until you see it work. This Savannah show is holiday comedy built from your suggestions, turning the usual Santa-and-family-fuss themes into something you cannot repeat. I love the fully improvised format, and I also like that audience participation is optional, so you can laugh without being put on the spot.

One thing to keep in mind: the show may include adult language, so it is best for adults and for older teens who enjoy comedy that can go off-script.

Key highlights you should know before you go

Totally Made-Up Hallmark Christmas Movie - Key highlights you should know before you go

  • A brand-new holiday storyline each time: the show is built on what you and others suggest.
  • 90 minutes of improv energy: expect games, songs, and fast changes rather than a fixed script.
  • Optional involvement: you can watch and enjoy, or raise your hand if you want a role.
  • True holiday-movie vibes: Santa, presents, reindeer, and awkward family moments show up in the mix.
  • Mobile ticket convenience: you receive a ticket you can use on your phone.
  • Adult-language possibility: check this if you are planning for a mixed-age group.

Front Porch Improv in Savannah: your 90-minute plan

Savannah does holiday well, but this experience goes for laughs instead of carols. You are heading to a comedy show from Front Porch Improv, and the whole point is that the performance is not prewritten. Instead, the cast shapes the action in real time, using ideas from the room and rolling it into a totally made-up holiday movie-style story.

This matters because it changes what you are paying for. You are not just buying a ticket to watch a show that will be the same tonight, next week, and next year. For your visit, the show is built from scratch, and that is a big part of the value at only $20 per person.

The timeframe is also clear: the show runs about 1 hour 30 minutes. That is long enough to feel like you got a full evening’s entertainment, but short enough that you can still do dinner or a walk after.

There is more Midnight in the Garden and Savannah film-location touring to track down

What the show is really like (and why it works)

Totally Made-Up Hallmark Christmas Movie - What the show is really like (and why it works)
The premise is simple: the cast performs a brand-new holiday comedy, created on the spot. They blend improv games and catchy songs with whatever ideas the audience brings into the room. The result is holiday storytelling full of familiar elements—Santa, presents, reindeer, and those awkward family party moments that everyone recognizes—but twisted into something new.

Here is why this kind of improv often lands better than people expect: the comedy is reactive. If the cast catches a theme from the room—an idea, a character type, or a gag direction—the show pivots quickly. That keeps the pace up and makes it feel like you are watching a movie scene get rewritten in front of you.

And yes, it is movie-like. You get the feeling of a holiday film happening, but without the predictability. If you like holiday movies but want them turned sideways with jokes, this is a good fit.

The real deal on audience participation

Totally Made-Up Hallmark Christmas Movie - The real deal on audience participation
The show is built for laughs whether you participate or not. Audience participation is described as totally optional, which is great if you are shy, traveling with people who would rather watch, or just want to keep your evening low-pressure.

That said, improv audiences can still influence the show even when you do not step into it. Your suggestions might be used, and the performers may nudge the room to give them ideas. So you can stay seated and enjoy it—or, if you are feeling brave, you might choose to jump in.

My practical tip: if you are on the fence, decide before the lights go down. Once the show is running, it is easier to go with the flow and harder to overthink it.

Stop 1: arriving at Front Porch Improv and getting settled fast

Totally Made-Up Hallmark Christmas Movie - Stop 1: arriving at Front Porch Improv and getting settled fast
Your whole itinerary centers on one stop: Front Porch Improv. When you arrive, the box office team greets you and helps you quickly get your ticket. Since it is a mobile ticket, you are not dealing with a paper handoff. Bring your phone and make sure it is charged.

After tickets, there is time to grab a drink or popcorn at the bar. That small pre-show window matters more than it sounds. A little snack and a quick chat with staff and other attendees helps you settle into the comedy mindset before the performance starts.

Then the lights dim, and the show begins. This is the moment you will feel the shift from holiday outing to live improv machine—performers start building scenes, games, and songs in real time, guided by audience input.

The show’s structure: games, songs, and holiday chaos

Totally Made-Up Hallmark Christmas Movie - The show’s structure: games, songs, and holiday chaos
You are looking at around 90 minutes of performance, and the format blends a few different kinds of improv. Expect improv games that help the cast get energy up and reactions flowing. Expect catchy songs—because holiday comedy tends to land better when it gives you a sing-along hook, even if you do not know the melody ahead of time.

Then comes the movie-like storytelling. The cast ties it together using classic holiday markers. That includes Santa, presents, and reindeer, plus those awkward family get-togethers that always come with misunderstandings and too much talking. Even when things veer into nonsense, they do it in a way that feels like a holiday film scene.

One more practical note: adult language is possible. That does not mean it is a rough show, but it does mean you should treat it as comedy for adults. If you are bringing teens, judge based on their comfort with adult comedy.

Value for $20: what you’re paying for (and what you’re not)

Totally Made-Up Hallmark Christmas Movie - Value for $20: what you’re paying for (and what you’re not)
At $20 per person, this is priced like an accessible night out, not a premium theater production. And that is exactly what makes it a smart value for the right traveler.

You are paying for:

  • A one-of-a-kind performance shaped by your suggestions
  • A long-enough show (1.5 hours) to justify the time
  • Live energy, including games and songs rather than just dialogue

You are not paying for:

  • A fixed script you can replay in your head afterward
  • A guided tour of historic sights (this is entertainment first)

If you like comedy, enjoy novelty, and are okay with the unpredictable nature of improv, the cost makes sense. If you only want a polished, scripted holiday storyline, you might find improv style jarring. The key is matching your mood to the format.

Location and getting there: keeping the evening simple

Totally Made-Up Hallmark Christmas Movie - Location and getting there: keeping the evening simple
The show is in Savannah, and it is described as near public transportation. That is helpful if you do not want to worry too much about driving or parking.

Also, service animals are allowed, which is useful to know for accessibility planning.

One more small detail that helps: confirmation is received at the time of booking. So you will not be scrambling later to find details.

Who this show suits best

Totally Made-Up Hallmark Christmas Movie - Who this show suits best
This experience tends to fit best if you:

  • Want a fun, low-stakes night out with a crowd
  • Like adult-friendly comedy with some unpredictability
  • Enjoy holiday themes, even when they get turned into jokes
  • Prefer entertainment where you can watch comfortably and still feel involved

It is especially good for adults in your group who want something playful rather than overly traditional. The energy level is a big part of the appeal, and the cast focuses on engaging the room—so the show works even if you come just to laugh.

When to book (and how not to miss out)

Shows like this can sell out, and the booking pattern supports that. On average, it is booked about 17 days in advance, which is a helpful clue: plan ahead if you want a good choice of days.

My advice: pick your date early, then book once you know you are staying in Savannah around that time. If you wait until the last minute, you risk showing up with no seats left.

Should you book it?

Book it if you want a holiday evening that feels different from the usual scripted entertainment. $20 for a one-night-only, audience-influenced improv comedy is strong value, especially if your group enjoys spirited comedy and optional participation.

Pass on it (or at least think carefully) if you strongly prefer clean, family-only scripts, or if adult language would be a dealbreaker. Also, if unpredictability makes you uncomfortable, this is built to be spontaneous—so it is not the right match.

If you like holiday movies but want them flipped into jokes right in front of you, this is an easy yes.

FAQ

FAQ

Where is the experience located?

The experience takes place in Savannah, USA.

How much does it cost?

It costs $20.00 per person.

How long is the show?

The show lasts approximately 1 hour 30 minutes.

Is the show improvised?

Yes. The holiday comedy show is fully improvised based on audience suggestions.

Do I have to participate?

No. Audience participation is totally optional.

Will the show include adult language?

It may include adult language.

Do I get a mobile ticket?

Yes. Your admission ticket is provided as a mobile ticket.

How soon do I need to cancel for a full refund?

You can cancel up to 24 hours in advance for a full refund. If you cancel less than 24 hours before the start time, you will not be refunded.

Is the venue near public transportation, and are service animals allowed?

The experience is near public transportation, and service animals are allowed.